Whip up some Keto Honey Mustard in a flash with 3 simple ingredients.
At no additional cost to you, I may make a small commission for purchases made through links in this post.
Jump to RecipeKeto Honey Mustard with only 3 ingredients?
Ready in 3 minutes?
Where has this recipe been all your life?!
There really isn’t a whole lot better than honey mustard when it comes to dippin’ chicken, am I right? That sweet tang has my heart on a string, I just cannot resist the stuff!
I’ve been making all sorts of crispy chicken from burgers to nuggets and strips. Caesar dressing just wasn’t cutting it anymore so I decided enough was enough, I would find a honey substitute to replace the honey in my honey mustard recipe.
I finally stumbled across one from natures hollow and omg, YOU GUYS! This Keto Honey Mustard is SO. DANG. DELICIOUS! Like, got not right to be this dang delicious, no right at all. Got me dippin’ my whole fridge just to have an excuse to dive further into that bowl of goodness.
Pretty sure Zoey thinks I’m a little cuckoo because I was literally dancing around my house with a half eaten chicken tender in one hand, mouth full and and basically intoxicated with a mouth sensory explosion.
It was a little awkward.
Maybe you should try this dip alone for the first time?
Either way, I hope you love this Keto Honey Mustard as much as I do!
What you’ll need to make this Keto Honey Mustard
3 ingredients! That’s it!
All you need is yellow mustard, mayonnaise and a honey substitute!
Depending on what you are using this Keto Honey Mustard for, you can add a pinch of sea salt. For example, I would add the sea salt if I was using this as a dip for chicken tenders, but would skip the salt if using on a sandwich spread or as a salad dressing.
Another ingredient to try is cayenne. Add a pinch to spice up this dip for an added flavour bonus.
How to make Keto Honey Mustard
Mix all three ingredients together and mix. It’s that simple!
Whisk in sea salt and/or cayenne if desired.
Store in the refrigerator in an air tight container.
Honey substitute
I am pretty pumped about this honey substitute I have just discovered, made my Nature’s Hollow. There are so many excellent recipes I can now make, starting with this epic Keto Honey Mustard.
I found this Sugar Free Honey Substitute at amazon, and though it’s fairly pricey, it’s sooo worth it. It’s sweetened with xylitol and only has 1 g net carbs per 1 tbsp.
The best part? It tastes exactly like honey without any aftertaste.
Is there a honey substitute you like to use? Let me know what it is in the comment section below so that I can give it a try!
What to make with Keto Honey Mustard
Now that you’ve got it, what can you make with it?
My favourite way to use this Keto Honey Mustard is for dippin’ chicken, whether it be nuggets or Crunchy Low Carb Baked Chicken Tenders, it’s absolutely THE BEST!
Ever tried a honey mustard chicken burger? Bread skinless boneless chicken breasts with the same coating as these chicken tenders, then load up a 90 Second Keto Bread with honey mustard and some lettuce. You’ve got yourself an epic burger!
It might sound crazy, but one of my favourite sandwiches of all time is a grilled ham and swiss with honey mustard! Load up a 90 Second Keto Bread or an Everything Bagel with honey mustard, swiss cheese and ham, then grill to perfection! 😋
You came to this recipe for a reason, what are you making with this Keto Honey Mustard? Let me know in the comment section below!
Keto Honey Mustard Salad Dressing
Do you love honey mustard salad dressing? Delicious, right? This Keto Honey Mustard can easily be turned into a salad dressing.
Simply whisk in 1-2 tbsp white wine vinegar, until the desired consistency has been reached, and you’ve got yourself a super yummy Keto Honey Mustard Salad Dressing!
Love this recipe? Try these next:
Low Carb Teriyaki Sauce and Marinade
Subscribe to Mama Bear’s monthly newsletter to be kept up to date on the latest and greatest recipes!
Keto Honey Mustard
Ingredients
Keto Honey Mustard
- ½ cup mayonnaise
- ⅓ cup yellow mustard
- ¼ cup honey substitute
Optional Additions
- 1 pinch sea salt
- 1 pinch cayenne
For Salad Dressing
- 1 tbsp white wine vinegar
Instructions
- Combine the Keto Honey Mustard ingredients in a bowl and whisk.
- Add sea salt and/or cayenne is desired.
- To make a Keto Honey Mustard Salad Dressing, whisk in white wine vinegar.
Notes
Nutrition Facts
Nutrition facts are an estimate only! The ingredients you choose could have different nutritional values than the ingredients I have used.
* Net carb count excludes both fibre and sugar alcohols, because these do not affect blood sugar in most people.
Deduct fibre (0.3g) and sugar alcohols (5g) from the total carbs to get 0.8 g net carbs per serving.
I am always on the lookout for new ideas for dressings. Great to find this sauce recipe, as just adding vinegar can turn this dip into a salad dressing. Now that the snow’s finally melting away I am so looking forward to salad for lunch and dinner altogether!
Right?! No matter how much I love soup, the warm weather makes me want to have salad for lunch and dinner! Hope you enjoy!
I’m loving your keto recipes! With recipes like this sauce, you don’t really miss eating “normally”. This sounds so good – it would be so good with chicken fingers!!
Thanks Katherine! It is the BEST with chicken fingers!
I love honey mustard dressings, so I really need to give your keto honey mustard a try! It would be perfect on sandwiches and burgers too!
I can’t do crispy chicken burgers right now without it! Hope you enjoy Leanne 🙂
Oh wow – these nuggets and dip look amazing! I have to check out this Sugar Free Honey Substitute from Amazon!
Thanks Holly! It’s been a game changer for me!
I too dance when something tastes delicious! 🙂 Your honey mustard sauce looks scrumptious! I love how crispy the chicken looks too!
Thanks Elaine! I just can’t seem to help myself sometimes 🤷♀️
honey mustard is so great on so many things. love it with chicken, but also as a dressing. Throw a little horseradish in and it’s good on beef too 🙂
Yum that is a excellent idea about the horseradish, one I’m going to try very soon!
Wow…3 ingredients! It looks like something worth making (although I love honey 😉 ).
I do as well! It’s great to have a replacement so that I can still enjoy the flavour 😋
I’ve never heard of honey substitute before and I’m super curious to try! Especially since you say there is no aftertaste that’s amazing 🙂 Thanks for the recipe it sounds super simple to make which I love!
Thanks Kate! It has been a game changer for me because of how much I love honey!
Honey and mustard go well with almost everything! I’d love to try it with the addition of cayenne, it sounds so yummy and I love spicy sauces. I also had no idea about the honey substitute, great tip! 🙂
Thanks Jessica 🙂
I’m not Keto, but that won’t keep me from this goodness!!! I’m all about the sauces and this one is a fave!
Thanks Lorie! You can always sub the honey sub for regular honey if you aren’t concerned about the carbs 🙂
I’m super pumped about the Keto Honey Mustard! I never seen sugar free honey substitute I have to try it. What makes the sugar free honey sweet is it monkfruit?
Hey Gina! I was super pumped when I found it as well! It is actually xylitol 🙂
Nothing can beat this brilliant combination of mayo, mustard, and honey. Match made in heaven. Love the way you’ve combined flavors in this one. Its easy and quick
Thanks Pearl 🙂
Oh my yum! What a great and easy recipe for a favorite dip without the guilt!
Thanks Sara!
This is a great sauce! I could see myself dipping wings on this or pouring over some pulled pork.
Yummy, what excellent ideas Sharon!
I made this on Saturday to take to my sister who loves her keto diet and she absolutely loved it. She asked for the recipe and I know it will be her go-to dressing now.
Yay! I a so glad she loved it, thank you Jacquelyn for letting me know!